Forum Overview :: Deleted Posts
 
Morrowing vs Daggerfall... FIGHT! by Ice Cream Jonsey 03/19/2006, 1:02pm PST
I like them both, so there will be a terrible conclusion at the end. This is a great idea for a longer article, but quickly:

o APPROACHABILITY Trying to start Daggerfall is way too irritating to be worth the effort most of the time. You're always in the starter dungeon and it is wholly uninteresting. I'm going to spoil it because I hate it so much: there's a skeleton and an imp and a bear. The bear is not driving and it does not, in fact, even have a gun. The game that sold itself on just how random its dungeons were threw you in the same fucking one to begin each game. Terrible. Morrowind only has you waking up from being raped, repeatedily, at sea and throws you into a town. Much easier to get into and get going. ADVANTAGE: Morrowind!

o GRAPHICS The graphics on Daggerfall really don't hold up well. There's no retro nostalgia to them, and I am one of those guys that thinks the graphics on Bard's Tale and Jumpman and whatever were perfect. Obviously, they are better in Morrowind (I would still have to say that they are the best I've ever seen on my system) so this surprises nobody, but -- in 2003 -- they are so bad in Daggerfall that it's tough to go back. ADVANTAGE: Morrowind!

o SOUND Nobody cares, really, but the music in Daggerfall was excellent. Much better wandering-the-countryside tunes, I thought. (small) ADVANTAGE: Daggerfall!

o BUGS Save once and save often in Daggerfall. Worthless without the 2.13 patch, MM (if you can't find it, bust me a note) and even if you do have it, it's possible and likely that you'll get your character stuck in the dungeons in between walls or some shit like that. Maybe it was just me, but I had no bug problems with Morrowind. Nothing jumped out on me. I didn't have "faith" in the designers in Morrowind because in their previous effort there would be so many times I'd get frustrated at a quest and learn that the game fucked up and not me, but every time I got stuck in Morrowind on a quest the answer to my problem was that I blew it and not the game. However! Morrowind has one of those Safedisc checks running out of the box. Get the CD crack. (Later patches might even have the constant Safedisc checks turned off -- they certainly should have done that by now as it really slowed the game down.) ADVANTAGE: Morrowind!

o MODS I never installed one for Daggerfall; have really been happy with the ones I've placed in Morrowind. I got a sidekick, for instance, in Morrowind which really got me back into the game. There are an endless number of talented Failed Romeros all around the net and a lot of them put up good content for Morrowind. ADVANTAGE: Morrowind!

o TRAVEL Stupid-easy in Daggerfall, a pain in the ass (from what I've seen) in Morrowind. Daggerfall just asks that you get out of county lines and you can go anywhere you want by pegasii or landshark or faeire taxi or whatever. Just hit the "t" key or something. Morrowind -- again, from what I have seen -- requests you either find a "Silt Strider" (very nice to look at, but usually placed in an annoying spot in town) or a Magic Teleportation Booth from the Bethesda Magic Teleportation Company that is in most of the mage guilds. Fuck that shit. It went backwards and traveling became much more annoying in Morrowind. (Nice superjump spell from the get-go, though). ADVANTAGE: Daggerfall!

o NPCs Okay, here's where Daggerfall kicks the shit out of Morrowind -- the NPCs in the former move. They have a schedule. Inexplicably, they don't in Morrowind. Granted, that "schedule" in Daggerfall may mean that they spend 9 AM - 3 PM at the office and the rest of the day at home, but the effort is there, at least. Morrowind only barely lets you experience the "magic" of being a cat burglar. You went from a corrupt capitalistic realm in the first one where everyone could barely manage to put in seven and a half hours of sitting on their asses in their own shops to some sort of proletarian, Beksinski purgatory where the populace have their beds right next to their cash registers in the last game. They do, in Morrowind, at least recognize when you're trying to sell their own stolen shit back to them. More, the NPCs have just as little personality in both games. All the negatives from Daggerfall non-player characters are in Morrowind, with the additional disadvantage that they won't move unless you hit or shoot them. Fuck that. (big) ADVANTAGE: Daggerfall!

Anyway, to conclude -- I like the rogue classes when I only have one character, and Daggerfall always gave me a sense that I could skulk around and make a living by stealing. Morrowind never did that. Morrowind, by almost every measure, is the better game, but Daggerfall had a lot more soul. I guess what I mean to say is that Morrowind is the better game, but you'd probably have more fun with Daggerfall.


the dark and gritty...Ice Cream Jonsey!
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
The closest you'll get to an easy way to browse the deleted posts. by Creexul :( 03/13/2006, 6:02am PST NEW
    So Jsoh and I both finished Sacrifice finally. by Creexul :( 03/13/2006, 6:51am PST NEW
    Metroid Prime 2 by Rafiki 03/19/2006, 12:52pm PST NEW
    Viewtiful Joe by Forensic 03/19/2006, 12:58pm PST NEW
    Mega Man: battle network: Blue version by Mischief Maker 03/19/2006, 12:59pm PST NEW
    Morrowing vs Daggerfall... FIGHT! by Ice Cream Jonsey 03/19/2006, 1:02pm PST NEW
    Castlevania: Lament of Innocence == Rygar with vampires, except better by godamit 03/19/2006, 1:03pm PST NEW
    SSX3 (PS2) by Fussbett 03/19/2006, 1:04pm PST NEW
        Re: SSX3 (PS2) by Ivan Dork It 03/20/2006, 3:23am PST NEW
            It's an in-joke for that time period. by Fussbett 03/20/2006, 8:57am PST NEW
                no no no by Ivan Dork It 03/20/2006, 10:57pm PST NEW
                    Re: no no no by Fussbett 03/20/2006, 11:14pm PST NEW
                        Re: no no no by Ivan Dork It 03/21/2006, 3:40am PST NEW
                            Solved by Fussbett 03/21/2006, 9:50am PST NEW
    Crimson Skies (XBOX) by Funkula 03/19/2006, 1:05pm PST NEW
    Kirby Air Ride by Funkula 03/19/2006, 1:06pm PST NEW
    INC Reel Roundup and/or Cinema Showdown, pardner (plenty spoilers) by I need clarification 03/19/2006, 1:09pm PST NEW
    OH GOD THE SUCK! (Matrix 3) by Mischief Maker 03/19/2006, 1:10pm PST NEW
    Fire Emblem (GBA) by Funkula 03/19/2006, 1:11pm PST NEW
    So this Deus Ex 2 demo sure is short and small by Roop Dirump 03/19/2006, 1:13pm PST NEW
    MANHUNT (PS2) by Fussbett 03/19/2006, 1:14pm PST NEW
    KOTOR, PC by mrs. johnson 03/19/2006, 1:14pm PST NEW
    Medal of Honor: Rising Sun by Creexul ^_^ 03/19/2006, 1:15pm PST NEW
    Atari 10-in-1 by Ice Cream Jonsey 03/19/2006, 1:15pm PST NEW
        Gravitar by Ice Cream Jonsey 03/20/2006, 2:35am PST NEW
            Where did you get your Vectrex flashcart? Review plz. NT by Fussbett 03/20/2006, 9:00am PST NEW
    First impression: Godzilla Destroy all monsters (XBox) by Mischief Maker 03/19/2006, 1:16pm PST NEW
    Mech Assault (X-Box) by Mischief Maker 03/19/2006, 1:17pm PST NEW
        this really isn't a good review of this game :( by Weyoun Voidbringer 05/24/2009, 4:44pm PDT NEW
        ok I should do a real and honest review so the correct opinion is here by Weyoun Voidbringer 05/24/2009, 5:46pm PDT NEW
    Battlestar Galactica (X-Box) by Mischief Shai-hulud 03/19/2006, 1:18pm PST NEW
    Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King by FABIO 03/19/2006, 1:19pm PST NEW
        The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers (PS2) by FABIO 01/24/2007, 6:41am PST NEW
    Phantom Crash (XBOX) by Funkula 03/19/2006, 1:20pm PST NEW
    Age of Mythology: The Titans, worst demo ever by FABIO 03/19/2006, 1:21pm PST NEW
    Bujingai (PS2) (Jap) by Fussbett 03/19/2006, 1:25pm PST NEW
        Gackt the Gamer by Fussbett 06/23/2009, 12:53am PDT NEW
            I enjoyed this clip too much to say anything funny about it. by Zsenitanuki 06/30/2009, 2:28pm PDT NEW
    Ratchet And Clank -- Going Commando by Rigthbug 03/19/2006, 1:26pm PST NEW
        Re: Ratchet And Clank -- Going Commando NT by Quentin Beck 12/13/2007, 5:01am PST NEW
    Pithy review of Dynasty Tactics 2 by curst 03/19/2006, 1:28pm PST NEW
    Panzer Dragoon Orta (XBox) by Mischief Maker 03/19/2006, 1:28pm PST NEW
    I am TOTALLY freaked the fuck out right now (Beyond good & Evil) by Mischief Maker 03/19/2006, 1:31pm PST NEW
    NFL Street by Ice Cream Jonsey 03/19/2006, 1:32pm PST NEW
    Baldur's Gate 2 Dark Alliance 2 (Playstation 2) by Creexul ^_^ 03/19/2006, 1:33pm PST NEW
    Re: A bitter appraisal by Kab(uke) Seme by Kab(uke) Seme 03/19/2006, 1:35pm PST NEW
    Kohan: Immortal Sovereigns by FABIO 03/19/2006, 1:36pm PST NEW
    Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic by elwonko 03/20/2006, 1:24pm PST NEW
    Final Fantasy: Crystal Chronicles- first two hours impressions by FABIO 03/20/2006, 1:26pm PST NEW
    Mac fans: still flaming homos. by Fussbett 03/20/2006, 1:28pm PST NEW
    It kicks ass. by Frank McGillicutty 03/20/2006, 1:31pm PST NEW
    Metroid: Zero Mission (GBA) by Voyons Donc 03/20/2006, 1:32pm PST NEW
    Zone of the Enders 2 full review by Mischief Zero-Shift 03/20/2006, 1:33pm PST NEW
        Zwwwweeee fighting? by Souffle of Pain 02/07/2007, 11:54am PST NEW
            There was a link that was lost in the transfer by MMore Woman than you'll ever have 02/07/2007, 1:15pm PST NEW
                It was that pussy bitch who posts as me by Souffle of Pain 02/07/2007, 1:20pm PST NEW
    Colin McRae Rally 04 (PS2 EURO) by Fussbett 03/20/2006, 1:48pm PST NEW
    Along those lines by Mischief Maker 03/20/2006, 1:53pm PST NEW
    Culdcept (PS2) by Fussbett 03/20/2006, 1:54pm PST NEW
        Reactions by Fussbett 03/20/2006, 3:45pm PST NEW
    The Chronicles of Riddick: Escape from Butcher Bay by Fussbett 03/20/2006, 4:41pm PST NEW
        That one didn't get deleted. But I approve of the effort. NT by Fussbett 03/20/2006, 10:09pm PST NEW
    Silent Hill 3 (PS2) (PAL version) by Fussbett 03/20/2006, 4:43pm PST NEW
    AIM log review of Everything or Nothing. by Creexul ^_^ 03/21/2006, 5:50pm PST NEW
    Ninja Gaiden: I love this game!/I HATE THIS MOTHERFUCKING COCKSUCKING GAME! by Mischief Maker 03/21/2006, 5:51pm PST NEW
    The Suffering by curst 03/21/2006, 5:52pm PST NEW
    Review: Samurai Warriors by False 03/21/2006, 5:53pm PST NEW
    Red Dead Revolver (PS2) by Fussbett 03/21/2006, 5:58pm PST NEW
    Siren: Curst was right by FABIO 03/21/2006, 5:59pm PST NEW
    More Broussard forum posts by Fussbett 03/21/2006, 6:02pm PST NEW
        Front page this, please NT by Souffle of Pain 03/21/2006, 8:34pm PST NEW
            It's old though. NT by Fussbett 03/22/2006, 11:24am PST NEW
        I know it goes without saying, but Fussbett and INC make the best logs. by Jerry Whorebach 05/24/2009, 5:12pm PDT NEW
            jhoh NT by Weyoun Voidbringer 05/24/2009, 5:48pm PDT NEW
                I'm relieved Jhoh is publishing the book, because it sounds like a lot of work. NT by Fussbett 05/24/2009, 8:26pm PDT NEW
                    Then when it comes out it's all switched with Mranduh logs. 8( NT by Creexuls, a monster >:3 05/25/2009, 1:41am PDT NEW
    JUNK II by Fussbett 03/21/2006, 6:10pm PST NEW
        Dvorak saying there were great 3D0 games is still as good now as it was then NT by Ice Cream Jonsey 05/24/2009, 5:18pm PDT NEW
    Junk by Fussbett 03/21/2006, 11:00pm PST NEW
 
powered by pointy