Forum Overview :: Gamerasutra
 
A less ad-hominem but still frothing-at-the-mouth reply to this charge by curst 06/02/2003, 10:16am PDT
Fabio - I even *agree* with you that some of P:T's fed-ex-like quests were pretty dull. And I think the BG series did AD&D combat far, far better.

However - [i]how the high motherfistfucking unholy betentacled rape demons of FUCK does that make P:T a Sierra-like adventure game in any way?![/i]

The Sierra games that sucked didn't suck because of you having to go to point B and get item C to help you get past point A. They sucked because there is no fucking way of figuring out some of the puzzles without cheating. Or because they tossed in those indefuckingscribably stupid spiral stairs/narrow mountain ledge/beanstalk navigation screens that were nigh fucking impossible to get past without repeated attempts and did nothing but serve to PISS THE PLAYER THE FUCK OFF. Or because (I remember you mentioning the cat/mouse in KQ5 up as an example, and it is a great one) you'd enter a room and see something that didn't really seem important and shrug it off and suddenly WHOOPS THE GAME IS COMPLETELY FUCKING OVER even though the game wouldn't point that out to you and would let you play without reason or hope of success for hours on end much like a retard trying to shove the square peg into the round hole of his Fisher Price game by using his tongue, allowing you to live in the delusion that you'll eventually be able to win even though you won't until you restart and take notice of the completely fucking unnoteworthy event that happened earlier or whatever.

P:T had its (so minor that I'm still amazed they ruined the game for you) problems, but it is NOTHING like Sierra games, unless you want to compare it to the great Sierra games in one sense: it, like them, is a great game.
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
Kojima on the future of video games by Colonel K 05/31/2003, 6:10am PDT NEW
    Re: Kojima on the future of video games by Lizard_King 05/31/2003, 1:42pm PDT NEW
        Re: Kojima on the future of video games by Mood: Perplexed 05/31/2003, 3:54pm PDT NEW
            Re: Kojima on the future of video games by Lizard_King 06/01/2003, 12:35pm PDT NEW
                Re: Kojima on the future of video games by FABIO 06/01/2003, 1:30pm PDT NEW
                    Re: Kojima on the future of video games by Lizard_King 06/05/2003, 3:24am PDT NEW
    japanese game designers by FABIO 06/01/2003, 1:22pm PDT NEW
        Re: japanese game designers by Jhoh Creexul 06/01/2003, 5:41pm PDT NEW
            I can tell you've never played Planescape: Torment NT by Senor Barborito 06/01/2003, 6:04pm PDT NEW
                THAT was dragged down by gay Sierra adventure elements NT by FABIO 06/01/2003, 7:54pm PDT NEW
                    ?! by Senor Barborito 06/01/2003, 8:12pm PDT NEW
                        hee hee by FABIO 06/01/2003, 8:15pm PDT NEW
                            Unsurprised by Senor Barborito 06/01/2003, 9:15pm PDT NEW
                                that's a long thesis for my one-line reply by FABIO 06/01/2003, 9:49pm PDT NEW
                                That was my theory, too! by I need clarification 06/01/2003, 11:23pm PDT NEW
                                    That gambit is more played out than a hair metal power ballad by Entropy Stew 06/02/2003, 12:56am PDT NEW
                                        Whoa! Hair metal power ballad?! Way to go, Dennis Miller! NT by I need clarification 06/02/2003, 1:21am PDT NEW
                                            That is nowhere near arcane enough for me by Dennis Miller 06/02/2003, 1:56am PDT NEW
                                                Re: That is nowhere near arcane enough for me by I need clarification 06/02/2003, 2:27am PDT NEW
                                                Re: That is nowhere near arcane enough for me by Entropy Stew 06/02/2003, 3:13am PDT NEW
                                            Whoa! Sarcasm?! Way to go, Dennis Miller! NT by Entropy Stew 06/02/2003, 3:28am PDT NEW
                                                Wait! How the hell did you thiink of that? Are you Dana Carvey? NT by I need clarification 06/02/2003, 3:40am PDT NEW
                                                    It's like having Joey Lawrence following me around and constantly saying "Whoa!" by Entropy Stew 06/02/2003, 4:59am PDT NEW
                                                        Don't project your Blossom fantasies on me, Mayim by I need clarification 06/02/2003, 6:16am PDT NEW
                                                            You lose. NT by Bugle Boy 06/02/2003, 11:52am PDT NEW
                                                            Way to take my 4am grammer down a notch, natch by Entropy Stew 06/02/2003, 3:22pm PDT NEW
                                                                Thanks! by I need clarification 06/02/2003, 8:53pm PDT NEW
                                                                    "Whoa!" NT by Entropy Stew 06/02/2003, 9:36pm PDT NEW
                                                                        "brevity of your levity" NT by I need clarification 06/02/2003, 9:55pm PDT NEW
                                                                            "Whoa!" NT by Entropy Stew 06/03/2003, 12:01am PDT NEW
                                                                                "Whoa!" NT by I need clarification 06/03/2003, 2:59am PDT NEW
                                        Speaking of double-replying... by I need clarification 06/02/2003, 6:18am PDT NEW
                                            ...what? NT by foogla 06/02/2003, 9:56am PDT NEW
                                                He's saying I'm gay for Barborito by Entropy Stew 06/02/2003, 3:18pm PDT NEW
                    A less ad-hominem but still frothing-at-the-mouth reply to this charge by curst 06/02/2003, 10:16am PDT NEW
                        Warrens lost my interest by FABIO 06/03/2003, 2:45am PDT NEW
                            Um by Senor Barborito 06/03/2003, 3:01am PDT NEW
                    Re: THAT was dragged down by gay Sierra adventure elements by STEVE LOLLERSON 06/02/2003, 12:14pm PDT NEW
                That's not a Japanese or Japanese-wannabe console game. NT by Jhoh Creexul 06/01/2003, 10:09pm PDT NEW
    Re: Kojima on the future of video games by Fussbett 06/02/2003, 3:25pm PDT NEW
 
powered by pointy