Forum Overview :: Gamerasutra
 
Here are some random comments. by Ice Cream Jonsey 08/09/2014, 8:02am PDT
skip wrote:

- Early Access has burned everyone out on funding unfinished games.


Ha, I kind of think that indie game sites need to either cover games that aren't finished OR are 100% done. There was a stretch where it seemed that every game I was reading about was simply "announced" or in development. Never finished and purchasable. I mean, every game is the best game ever if you're talking about screenshots and concept art and features. It isn't until you start playing and see that the thing won't let you remap controls or that it's got more tearing than bicyclists through four-way stops (TOPICAL) (Sorry).


- There's too many of them. Even weeding out obviously broken games, there's too many games that are 6-7/10 coming out. Even really good games have the "but flawed" caveat.


I'd guess, with no science whatsoever, that the fourth hour of an indie game is probably played by 1% of the people who buy the game. There are a ton of them and I wish they were shorter. A lot of flaws come from how dragged-out they are.


- There's something to be said for PR. Phil Fish and some of the Kickstarter updates have shown that some designers don't even know how to interact with other human beings on a basic level, let alone as a company to a customer.


Back in the 90s, one of the members of the iD team was the "biz" guy and I think that if you're going to have an indie team made up of separate people it should be programmer, musician, graphic artist, writer, public relations. But PR is just as big as any of the others, in terms of getting the game noticed and spoken about. I guess what I am saying is that it's always been that way, I just didn't respect PR until recently.


- Humble Bundle and the app store have devalued these games. There's now so many for so cheap, it's hard to keep up with the news coverage.


What bugs me is that there's no decent way to evaluate the games when I get an e-mail about them weekly. The number of games doesn't matter. The price for all of them will always be between 2 and 6 bucks. I'd kind of like to have, in an e-mail, the name of the game, a representative screenshot, the genre and notes if the developer has done other games. Instead, Indie Royale gives you this one image, divided up into six slices that tell you nothing except the title.

(Apologies for the random comments that don't go anywhere or really have anything to do with anything. I will change the title to reflect this.)


the dark and gritty...Ice Cream Jonsey!
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
Why Do So Many People Hate Indie Games? by IGN by skip 08/08/2014, 10:25pm PDT NEW
    The whole value proposition is stupid to begin with. by Jerry Whorebach 08/08/2014, 11:52pm PDT NEW
        Oh man, some of those numbers are way off. IGNORE ANY NUMBERS IN THIS POST. by Jerry Whorebach 08/09/2014, 6:23am PDT NEW
        This thread does bring up a critical reason for why people hate indie games by serial malcontent 08/09/2014, 8:08am PDT NEW
            He didn't save all the kids. NT by Worm,Ed Gein 08/09/2014, 8:49am PDT NEW
    Here are some random comments. by Ice Cream Jonsey 08/09/2014, 8:02am PDT NEW
        Re: Here are some random comments. by serial malcontent 08/09/2014, 8:14am PDT NEW
    Re: Why Do So Many People Hate Indie Games? by IGN by Souffle of Pain 08/09/2014, 10:09am PDT NEW
        I've started relying more on video reviews too by skip 08/09/2014, 5:29pm PDT NEW
            That's the real reason companies try to shut down Let's Play videos by fabio 08/10/2014, 4:42pm PDT NEW
            That's the real reason companies try to shut down Let's Play videos by fabio 08/10/2014, 4:46pm PDT NEW
    Count me as someone that never wants to play another sidescrolling platformer by E. L. Koba 08/09/2014, 6:46pm PDT NEW
        Understandable, though to me the type of platformer matters a lot. by Jerry Whorebach 08/09/2014, 8:07pm PDT NEW
            That's a touch unfair by skip 08/09/2014, 11:41pm PDT NEW
                Wait, aren't you the guy who takes narrative dance classes twice a month? by Jerry Whorebach 08/10/2014, 5:56pm PDT NEW
    I liked Dear Escher... by blackwater 08/14/2014, 10:33pm PDT NEW
    Why critics love Mountain, but Steam users are calling it "worthless" by PCGamer by skip 08/22/2014, 5:23pm PDT NEW
        Re: Why critics love Mountain, but Steam users are calling it "worthless" by PCG by E. L. Koba 08/22/2014, 6:21pm PDT NEW
        People used to pay money for interesting screensavers. by Fullofkittens 08/22/2014, 7:27pm PDT NEW
            Re: People used to pay money for interesting screensavers. by Butterface Loving Lollerson 08/22/2014, 7:41pm PDT NEW
            I feel like we as a species solved this riddle a long time ago. by Jerry Whorebach 08/22/2014, 8:42pm PDT NEW
                Digital leisure is a good term for it. NT by Ice Cream Jonsey 08/22/2014, 9:53pm PDT NEW
 
powered by pointy