Forum Overview :: No Stairway to Heaven
 
Bands I hated even though people I wanted to be friends with recommended them by to me, Zseni 06/26/2007, 8:49pm PDT
1. Final Fantasy

Recommended by: posh Indian girl going to posh hip NYC college

Why I believed: she liked other stuff I liked!

Why it sucked: whiny smarty posh dude with whiny violin - are you joking? Where is the MUSIC? I can't dance to your SMARTNESS, buddy. If I wanted to read your snotty poetry, I'd hit your myspace page up. You are so FUCKING TWEE.

2. The Decemberists

Recommended by: former roomie, former buddy

Why I believed: "they like, you know, pirates and stuff, but the music is great too. Every song is like a 18th C. tragedie."

Why it sucked: whiny smarty posh dudes with whiny harmoniums - are you joking? You call THIS a tragedy? This sounds like what would happen if the Goonies were in their late 20s and Mikey's attic had been full of instruments instead of treasure maps. They're so FUCKING TWEE.

3. The Arcade Fire

Recommended by: everybody in the universe, INCLUDING David Bowie, whose taste is historically impeccable

Why I believed: David Bowie, man! I didn't think he was capable of calling a bad shot!

Why it sucked: it is legendary - as soon as I hit the bit about "our parent's bedrooms" in "Tunnels", I flicked the fucking album off forever. The INSTANT a dude starts talking about shit that happens in his mom's napping lair, I am not interested in his psychological state, life philosophy, or musical phantasie. He is dead to me. That whole band is dead to me, and not all the critical applause in the world can restore its corpse to life. The bedroom of parents is a place in which a family spirit dwells. It is a private and signal honor to approach the bedroom of one's OWN parents, and a heartless invasion of privacy to scurry into the bedroom of someone else's parents. The kind of slipshod faggot who strolls into MY PARENTS' BEDROOM and has the nerve to tell me about it is a motherfucker with a target on his forehead. He ain't worth any more time than it takes to get a bead on him.

The Arcade Fire could be the greatest band that ever happened to the history of the planet, but their music can never rise to the level of their discourtesy.

Plus, they are twee.

4. The Aluminum Group

Recommended By: Cool-ass dudes in the only Soulseek chatroom that didn't kickban me within two sentences

Why I believed: these guys are so cool!!!!1!

Why it sucks: if you took all the musical cleverness out of Steely Dan and filled in the hole with more obvious lyrical cleverness, you're getting close to the best of Aluminum Group. But 1) Steely Dan is boring even WITH the musical cleverness and 2) I don't like obvious lyrical cleverness. Plus all their albums would not be out of place at middle-class-with-pretensions havens of all sorts. They are not nearly as clever as they think they are, those middle class people with pretensions!

5. Sufjan Stevens

Recommended By: Caltrops posters. :(

Why I believed: I'm friends with Caltrops, aren't I?

Why it sucks: C'mon and feel the twee imaginary twee indie rock twee Illinoise. A brutal date rape of an album, which promised me happy reunions with my glorious, cold, square, lake-faced hometown, and instead delivered twee Bob Dylanisms of an Illinois without the oppressive flatness, the elegant fingers of rivers, the tall granite Modernist buildings, the implacable and shivering heart of a winter which breaks suddenly as a fever.... how could he prefer the ordinary imaginary dramas of bible school students in place of the stern flows of transit and capital which etch the face of the city as surely as time and water would a canyon? How could he be so twee and boring?!




CALTROPS, PLEASE ADVISE:

Why is there so much twee in the air these days? I mean seriously. If you have to pick between camp and twee, PICK CAMP. Twee is the last resort of the rhetorically prepubescent.
NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
Bands I hated even though people I wanted to be friends with recommended them by to me, Zseni 06/26/2007, 8:49pm PDT NEW
    Bands I hated even though people I wanted to be friends with recommended them by Jhoh Cable o_O 06/26/2007, 8:57pm PDT NEW
        a musical interpretation of the Cable Brothers posting. by Zseni 06/26/2007, 10:56pm PDT NEW
    The part where you stopped in the middle of the first song on Funeral is coincid NT by Fullofkittens 06/26/2007, 9:16pm PDT NEW
        dentally where I stopped reading your post. (Some bizarre confessional angle) NT by Fullofkittens 06/26/2007, 9:17pm PDT NEW
            Using two subject lines is the internet equivalent of parking in two spaces. by Jerry Whorebach 06/26/2007, 9:56pm PDT NEW
                You can park in two spaces at Zsenimart (it's not even OPEN) NT by Fullofkittens 06/26/2007, 10:22pm PDT NEW
                    I have lenient policies because I have interesting customers. by Zseni 06/26/2007, 10:38pm PDT NEW
            I don't need Arcade Fire fans reading my precious posts. NT by Zseni 06/26/2007, 10:10pm PDT NEW
                The other problem with the arcade fire by motherfuckerfoodeater 06/26/2007, 10:21pm PDT NEW
    That's a white orc, with white problems. NT by Zeus Carver 06/27/2007, 1:27am PDT NEW
        Hey Zeus, this a friend of your's? NT by Jhoh Cable o_O 06/27/2007, 9:46am PDT NEW
    Re: Bands I hated even though people I wanted to be friends with recommended the by Jerry Whorebach 06/27/2007, 5:54am PDT NEW
        Re: Bands I hated even though people I wanted to be friends with recommended the by Zseni 06/27/2007, 10:03am PDT NEW
            Zsensi posts from the heart, like BDR. We fall in love with people like that. NT by Quentin Beck 06/27/2007, 7:52pm PDT NEW
            Re: Bands I hated even though people I wanted to be friends with recommended the by Jerry Whorebach 07/06/2007, 11:04pm PDT NEW
                Let's Dance NT by Modern Love is the pinnacle of his 07/06/2007, 11:06pm PDT NEW
                Just get Changes (his best of). NT by Jhoh Cable :( 07/07/2007, 3:16am PDT NEW
                    Changes: not terrible by motherfuckerfoodeater 07/07/2007, 8:36am PDT NEW
                        Re: Changes: not terrible by I need clarification 07/07/2007, 1:40pm PDT NEW
                Re: Bands I hated even though people I wanted to be friends with recommended the by Zseni 07/07/2007, 6:54am PDT NEW
                    Review: Sound+Vision by Jerry Whorebach 07/11/2007, 2:07am PDT NEW
    You've had almost three years to get over the Arcade Fire. by 2004 06/27/2007, 10:08am PDT NEW
    Whoa, you guys never answered my question about tweeness. by Zseni 06/28/2007, 4:19am PDT NEW
        Short answer: because heavy rock and rap has been the mainstream for awhile. NT by Fullofkittens 06/28/2007, 6:14am PDT NEW
            Or just rap, and raprock. NT by Jhoh Cable o_O 06/28/2007, 6:41pm PDT NEW
        I AM GOING TO SEE THE WHITE STRIPES ON SUNDAY by Ray of Light 07/06/2007, 11:42pm PDT NEW
            He's not really her brother, he's her ex-husband. They just pretend :) NT by Jerry Whorebach 07/07/2007, 1:03am PDT NEW
                Everyone knows this. Ray looks a fool. NT by Quentin Beck 07/08/2007, 4:55am PDT NEW
                    He's sensitive about his looks. NT by Thanks to Sassy. 07/08/2007, 4:56am PDT NEW
                    Everyone who's read their Wikipedia entry, like I have. NT by Wikipedia Brown 07/08/2007, 7:03am PDT NEW
                    You're proud of your knowledge of White Stripes lore. NT by Cool people, laughing. 07/08/2007, 9:33am PDT NEW
            They were good! by Ray of Light 07/09/2007, 7:32am PDT NEW
                Turn the tables. Take the tall person dancing. by Quentin Beck 07/09/2007, 6:45pm PDT NEW
    It turns out we all hated Steven Seagal's music. NT by Maybe... maybe we should break up? 06/28/2007, 11:53am PDT NEW
 
powered by pointy