Forum Overview :: Operation: Hammer Time
 
Blair HAD to score a home run, Bush had enough support already. by SBDMT 03/19/2003, 9:22am PST
Zebco Fuckface wrote:

Diotallevi wrote:

Entropy Stew wrote:

That fucking rocked
I mean, I know style matters, but does it matter to YOU?


I think the means matters quite a bit, even when working for good ends.


Bush may not be re-elected in '04, but neither is he facing the political suicide that Blair may be. I happen to think Bush is at least earnest in his speeches, but certainly not a natural orator; it's especially evident how uncomfortable he while is speaking into the camera from an empty room. Juxtapose that with how jovial(and unpredictable)he is in those off-the-cuff moments during impromptu interviews. Check out tha HBO featurette Journeys with George sometime, no matter how much you may despise him the piece shows him to be fairly engaging.

Enough about that though, back to everyone's preoccupation with the comparison: Blair had to knock 'em dead and get that vote. And even that wasn't my fucking point(not that I haven't enjoyed the discussion). It was his delivery as much, if not more, than the message. To merely read the text of the speech may lead one to believe it was just a concise, clinical presentation of charges, evidence, and a prescribed course of action. Blair had done this on several prior occasions with the same evidence, the difference in this one being the passion, the heart he poured out in that assembly.

True story:
I had been working nights this past week, and given the recent acceleration of events, I had been trailing off to sleep with one of the various 24HR news channels on in the background. Tuesday morning was no different, only my sleep was a bit restless. I had kind of drifted into that halucinatory sub-aware dreamstate where you are just enough disconnected from your surroundings to drift off towards sleep, but just enough aware of your surroundings that they become the focal point of your dreams. Actually, I dunno if any of you have any idea what the fuck I'm on about here, it may just be that I'm a mutant or something, but this is quite common for me. Anyways, I had been drifting back and forth between short bouts of unconsiousness and erratic dreams about being a soldier on the Kuwaiti border. Each one brought me a little closer to the danger, and each time I was awakened mid-dream by a soundbite from the Blair speech on TV. I forget the *exact* context of the dream, but it involved my unit escorting SAS troopers on a SCUD-busting mission, and just as I was sending coordinates to the gunner or whatthefuckever the full speech kicked in.

I'd say about two minutes or so ticked off before I was fully awake and lucid, but once I realized who was talking and what he was saying, I locked in. Who can say if the natural buzz I was feeling had anything to do with my reception of his speech, but several times as he punctuated his message with emotional crecendo I found myself clinching my fists. Here's this guy, from a country and ideology that, at times, seem a world apart from my own, who seems to be willing to follow my crazy-ass government into Hell. Up until now I had, in spite of my own belief that our current course is just, felt pity for Blair. I worried that our leadership had him roped and would drag him over some cliff in the name of solidarity. I felt genuinely bad for what we were doing to him, his reputation, and his career. Then I heard the guy speak. Right there, flanked by the government he represented(which now wanted his head), having just suffered what pretty much every expert considered the deathblow to his support of military action by virtue of the U.N. security council's rejection of the british resolution, he faced them with a conviction and fortitude I can't recall ever seeing a world leader show before. Not in "This aggression will not stand", not in "Mr Gorbachev, tear down this wall", not even in "Ask not what your country can do for you...".

Consider his closing statement:

Tell our allies that at the very moment of action, at the very moment when they need our determination that Britain faltered. I will not be party to such a course. This is not the time to falter. This is the time for this house, not just this government or indeed this prime minister, but for this house to give a lead, to show that we will stand up for what we know to be right, to show that we will confront the tyrannies and dictatorships and terrorists who put our way of life at risk, to show at the moment of decision that we have the courage to do the right thing.

I beg to move the motion.


That may or may not move some of you, but to hear it from the source cause the hairs on my arms to stand straight up. My pity is foolishly wasted on this man, for it is I who would follow him into hell.

PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
Tony Blair needs a wheelbarrow for his balls. by SBDMT 03/18/2003, 7:15pm PST NEW
    I dunno how it got duped...but ignore the other one by Doh 03/18/2003, 7:28pm PST NEW
    Text of the speech by Diotallevi 03/18/2003, 8:06pm PST NEW
        Jesus, I wish Bush & co. could write/speak like that -nt- by Entropy Stew 03/18/2003, 8:45pm PST NEW
            Blair is more eloquent, but Bush is just as right by Diotallevi 03/18/2003, 8:55pm PST NEW
                I've been hovering on the line since forever by Entropy Stew 03/18/2003, 9:27pm PST NEW
                    Re: I've been hovering on the line since forever by Diotallevi 03/19/2003, 8:21pm PST NEW
                        I admit the French veto-promise fucking pissed me off by Senor Barborito 03/19/2003, 8:26pm PST NEW
                        France by Bob Violence 03/19/2003, 8:36pm PST NEW
                            Re: France by Steve Lollerson 03/19/2003, 10:00pm PST NEW
                                Re: France by Bob Violence 03/19/2003, 10:34pm PST NEW
                                Re: France by foogla 03/20/2003, 7:54am PST NEW
                Communication by Chemdem 03/18/2003, 10:02pm PST NEW
                Re: Blair is more eloquent, but Bush is just as right by Zebco Fuckface 03/19/2003, 5:28am PST NEW
                    Blair HAD to score a home run, Bush had enough support already. by SBDMT 03/19/2003, 9:22am PST NEW
        Rape button got plenty of use in the 'court of public opinion' by Soma, from the adopted home of LOTR 03/20/2003, 10:03pm PST NEW
 
powered by pointy