Forum Overview :: Mac Hall Complaints Department
 
Note the inability of ES and ragdoll ninja to determine where it went to shit by Mischief Shai-hulud 07/12/2009, 7:08pm PDT
This is because the quality of the books dropped suddenly, precipitously, and consistently. By the time these guys stopped, the quality had dropped so low that the shitty initial sequels didn't seem that bad in comparison. Dune was meant to be a complete novel by itself and was never intended to have sequels.

The same is true of the sequels to my other favorite Sci Fi novel of all time, Rendezvous with Rama.

Seriously ICJ, you should read Dune. You won't be disappointed.

BEWARE! DUNE SEQUEL SPOILERZ BELOW!
































































Dune 2:

Pail is emperor and ruler of the galaxy. Stilgar notes that his sister Alia is getting dangerously horny and needs a husband. Then someone tries to kill Paul with a shitty bomb that only blows up people's eyes. Despite Dune 1 having a plausible sci fi reason for Paul being able to predict the future, in this book Paul can still "see" for reasons unexplained. The fremen want Paul to go die in the desert, even though they literally now have all the money and resources in the galaxy and no need to cull weakened tribe members for suvival, much less their frigging messiah. Paul refuses because he wants to find the assassin. Then Chani dies in childbirth and Paul loses his magic vision because he's sad. But he sees the assassin in time and kills him. How? By using the sight of his newborn son, who magically has the mind of an adult and the ability to transfer his sight to Paul. Now that the assassin's dead, Paul goes to die in the desert. And Alia shacks up with a clone of Duncan Idaho.

Dune 3:

A whole new group of evil fremen appear! What makes them evil? Why, they waylay travelers and render them for their water. Isn't that exactly what Stilgar was planning to do to Paul and his mother? Well yeah, but he wasn't going to do it quite so evilly. And rumor has it, the evil Fremen have a man with no eyes and the ability to see the future. Could this be Paul??? Meanwhile Paul's twin kids have the combined memories of every single king in the world all the way back to ancient Egypt. Then someone tries to kill them. The sister goes into a deathlike trance while the brother flees to the desert and ends up in the hands of the evil fremen. There he runs into Paul, who laments that he didn't follow this whole kwisatz haderach thing through to the end. What end is that? Well the son covers his body with sand worm larva who bond to his body and form a suit of living armor giving him super speed and strength! And Alia goes crazy and dies.

Dune 4:

The son's sandworm armor has grown to massive size and he's a barely mobile jabba the hut-esque blob sitting on his throne. Then Duncan Idaho clone #327 enters the throne room and walks really close to the throne so he can shoot the son with his laser gun. Then in a scene that is not at all hilarious, the son jumps off his throne and squashes Idaho flat. Then he makes a mental note to order another Duncan Idaho clone.

AND THAT'S WHERE I QUIT! BOY THOSE SEQUELS WERE WORTH READING!
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
......... by FABIO 07/08/2009, 5:20am PDT NEW
    Coffee shop worked concerned that boyfriend is not meeting his full potential by mark 07/08/2009, 7:45am PDT NEW
        It looks like they're already married. by Creexuls, a monster >:3 07/08/2009, 7:56am PDT NEW
            After she makes him over into a responsible man she'll lose all interest in him. NT by Mischief Maker 07/08/2009, 10:42am PDT NEW
        Also: what resume. by laudablepuss 07/08/2009, 11:47am PDT NEW
            Yeah, he's going to send out FOUR resumes and wait for the offers to roll in. NT by Last 07/08/2009, 2:07pm PDT NEW
    This comic is going to kill me by Rafiki 07/08/2009, 3:36pm PDT NEW
    What is this comic written by a guy? Oh. by Creexuls, a monster >:3 07/09/2009, 9:58pm PDT NEW
        I'm not sure if working at a coffee shop is "functioning in the world" NT by Apologies to Jerry and Weyoun 07/09/2009, 10:09pm PDT NEW
            I never worked in a coffee shop, hipsters are the dumbest people ever NT by Weyoun Voidbringer 07/09/2009, 11:29pm PDT NEW
                Jerry aspires to drink at one. It's the world's shittiest life goal. NT by Quétinbec 07/10/2009, 12:05am PDT NEW
        My boyfriend is SUCH A FAG! *glee* NT by Rafiki 07/09/2009, 10:23pm PDT NEW
            She's gleeing because all the girls in QC are into Bishie cartoon pron. NT by Mischief Maker 07/10/2009, 7:28am PDT NEW
                And crying at cartoons makes him sensitive by Rafiki 07/10/2009, 9:14am PDT NEW
                    What was the Dune reference? by Ice Cream Jonsey 07/10/2009, 9:22am PDT NEW
                        The power of her words. NT by mark 07/10/2009, 10:10am PDT NEW
                            Words hurt worse than if someone froze a sledgehammer etc. NT by Creexuls, a monster >:3 07/10/2009, 10:45am PDT NEW
                            Psh, more like the power of her NERDS! by motherfuckerfoodeater 07/10/2009, 11:06am PDT NEW
                        You should read Dune. by Mischief Maker 07/10/2009, 12:34pm PDT NEW
                            The first two sequels are not bad by Entropy Stew 07/10/2009, 1:32pm PDT NEW
                                Re: The first two sequels are not bad by N 07/11/2009, 12:45pm PDT NEW
                                    There were gems in there, it was just HORRIBLY WRITTEN NT by Entropy Stew 07/11/2009, 6:08pm PDT NEW
                                        Note the inability of ES and ragdoll ninja to determine where it went to shit by Mischief Shai-hulud 07/12/2009, 7:08pm PDT NEW
                                            I'll read it. I saw spoiler warning! This is as far as I can go. NT by Ice Cream Jonsey 07/12/2009, 7:36pm PDT NEW
                                            You just pointed out the exact same progression of falling quality that I did by Entropy Stew 07/12/2009, 11:09pm PDT NEW
                                            Oh man, Rama II. by Arbit 07/13/2009, 9:39am PDT NEW
                                                Don't read 3001 either :( by Fussbett 07/13/2009, 11:13am PDT NEW
                                                    I've been listening to the James Bond novels on audiobook by I need clarification 07/13/2009, 11:25am PDT NEW
                                                        The golf scene is what stopped me from finishing Goldfinger by Mischief Shai-hulud 07/13/2009, 12:21pm PDT NEW
                                                            Are you new to english? The golf scene was great by bombMexico 07/13/2009, 11:28pm PDT NEW
                                                                I really like the hippie psychedelic ones by motherfuckerfoodeater 07/14/2009, 7:29am PDT NEW
                                                    Ender's Game sequels by FABIO 07/13/2009, 1:35pm PDT NEW
                                                        Speaker For The Dead was totally awesome compared to Xenocide. by Fullofkittens 07/13/2009, 1:56pm PDT NEW
                                                            This is what I get for posting from work. by Chairman Mao 07/13/2009, 2:02pm PDT NEW
                                                        Super super super horrible books. by Last 07/13/2009, 2:07pm PDT NEW
                                            This is in fact pretty much how Worm-Leto dies by Fortinbras 07/13/2009, 10:49am PDT NEW
        I thought she was excited that she could mock him for loving anime. NT by mark 07/09/2009, 10:25pm PDT NEW
            Apparently that's what it was, it's almost impossible to suppose what's happenin by Creexuls, a monster >:3 07/10/2009, 9:53am PDT NEW
            I think you're right. Didn't know they broke up. I don't feel bad about that eit NT by Rafiki 07/10/2009, 12:32pm PDT NEW
        The whole comic is Jeph's wank fantasy. He just happens to be a bottom. NT by Mischief Maker 07/10/2009, 7:03am PDT NEW
        Williamsburg, Brooklyn is the worst place on Earth by FABIO 07/11/2009, 12:44am PDT NEW
            Hipsters and indie rockers should be shot no trial no jury just straight to exec NT by Creexuls, a monster >:3 07/11/2009, 1:19am PDT NEW
            This is a good story, more please NT by Fortinbras 07/11/2009, 3:07am PDT NEW
                Williamsburg video by FABIO 07/11/2009, 11:26am PDT NEW
                    Haha, wire brush snare drum NT by E. L. Koba 07/11/2009, 11:40am PDT NEW
                        There's almost always a didgeridoo player there =( by FABIO 07/11/2009, 7:07pm PDT NEW
                    My wife used to teach in Bushwick. :( by Fullofkittens 07/11/2009, 11:57am PDT NEW
                        What part of Bushwick and what year? by FABIO 07/11/2009, 7:02pm PDT NEW
                            She took the JMZ to Myrtle Ave get there. =( by Fullofkittens 07/11/2009, 7:22pm PDT NEW
                    That dude is getting torn open on his own youtube comments. by Creexuls, a monster >:3 07/11/2009, 12:03pm PDT NEW
                        The comments stop at 6 months ago because that's when he starting moderating NT by Fussbett 07/11/2009, 2:07pm PDT NEW
                    oh god the mypsace page in the poetv comments by Rafiki 07/11/2009, 4:50pm PDT NEW
                        The problem with indie girls by FABIO 07/11/2009, 7:40pm PDT NEW
                            FABIO'S GONE ON DATES?! (PULLS FIRE ALARM) NT by Caltrops 07/11/2009, 7:50pm PDT NEW
                                Fortinbras' dreams crushed, back to getting yelled at by psycho girlfriend NT by FABIO 07/11/2009, 7:51pm PDT NEW
                                    His fat and psychopathic wife who will thrash him within an inch of his life. NT by Creexuls, a monster >:3 07/11/2009, 9:01pm PDT NEW
                                    Dreams of pounding FABIO in the ass or dreams of FABIO being a perpetual virgin? NT by Fortinbras 07/13/2009, 11:31pm PDT NEW
                            Re: The problem with indie girls by Creexuls, a monster >:3 07/11/2009, 9:02pm PDT NEW
                            Nice, Fabio. by Quétinbec 07/12/2009, 3:42pm PDT NEW
                                QB is gay counter +1 by FABIO 07/12/2009, 7:45pm PDT NEW
                                    Fabio likes his girls like he likes his games: he doesn't by Quétinbec 07/13/2009, 2:19am PDT NEW
                                        Red flags help you sift out gypsy thieves. Think of how many whores that stolen NT by video player could have bought! 07/13/2009, 3:30am PDT NEW
                                Re: Nice, Fabio. by Mischief Shai-hulud 07/12/2009, 7:48pm PDT NEW
                        Notice all his favorite books are for children by FABIO 07/11/2009, 7:54pm PDT NEW
            'Williamsburg is Dead' (blog) by Vested Id 07/11/2009, 11:50pm PDT NEW
                It's from the 'Company Picnic' episode of The Office (U.S.) NT by Gruman 07/12/2009, 12:04am PDT NEW
                Re: 'Williamsburg is Dead' (blog) by I need clarification 07/13/2009, 2:45pm PDT NEW
            I've stopped hating Williamsburg as much. by Chairman Mao 07/12/2009, 5:37pm PDT NEW
                so the recession has skinned and flayed hipsters? by Weyoun Voidbringer 07/12/2009, 6:21pm PDT NEW
                    Re: so the recession has skinned and flayed hipsters? by Chairman Mao 07/12/2009, 6:25pm PDT NEW
                        Hipsters + insane people, good mix. ^_^ by Creexuls, a monster >:3 07/12/2009, 6:43pm PDT NEW
                        haha, more Bedford! by FABIO 07/12/2009, 7:56pm PDT NEW
                            Re: haha, more Bedford! by Creexuls, a monster >:3 07/12/2009, 8:50pm PDT NEW
                                You will find no such prejudice in the East Village. NT by Fullofkittens 07/13/2009, 8:48am PDT NEW
                        So it's an entire town of Quentinbecs? NT by Mischief Shai-hulud 07/13/2009, 7:09pm PDT NEW
                            Basically. NT by Chairman Mao 07/13/2009, 10:42pm PDT NEW
                            Welcome to jokes of 2 days ago, PAL NT by FABIO 07/14/2009, 3:17am PDT NEW
                                I had COFFEE with McCauly........ by Creexuls, a monster >:3 07/14/2009, 3:18am PDT NEW
                                FINE. So it's a town entirely populated by Sophia Coppola move protagonists? NT by Mischief Shai-hulud 07/14/2009, 3:36pm PDT NEW
                Girls with tons and tons of guy friends is always a red flag by FABIO 07/12/2009, 8:57pm PDT NEW
            This is the best description of what it's like to live there I've ever read. NT by Cyril Badman 06/28/2010, 6:18pm PDT NEW
        Re: What is this comic written by a guy? Oh. by Creexuls, a monster >:3 07/11/2009, 6:06pm PDT NEW
    How's the job search going? by Creexuls, a monster >:3 07/14/2009, 6:19am PDT NEW
        What was that Yahtzee said about basing webcomics females off your mother? NT by Mischief Shai-hulud 07/14/2009, 6:41am PDT NEW
        Where does Blondie work to be so indignant? The coffee shop? NT by Worm 07/14/2009, 6:44am PDT NEW
            people who work > people who dont work, live with parents NT by Entropy Stew 07/14/2009, 7:25am PDT NEW
                Yeah and .0002>.0001 though who gives a shit? NT by Worm 07/14/2009, 7:34am PDT NEW
                    It's more like the difference between Dune book 3 and book 4 NT by Entropy Stew 07/14/2009, 10:49am PDT NEW
            Blondie?! Call her "COLERIDGE"! Jeph didn't give her a crazy unique name for n NT by Fussbett 07/14/2009, 11:00am PDT NEW
    official hipster thread? I dunno I just did a caltrops search anyway here is cr by Sword of Justice 06/28/2010, 9:18am PDT NEW
 
powered by pointy