Forum Overview :: The Walking Dead
 
The Walking Dead game by fabio 10/31/2012, 6:38pm PDT
So Telltale made a Walking Dead adventure game.

I'm not that far into it but I have no idea why everyone was raving about it. Every once in a while it throws a mildly entertaining quick time event at you, but most of it is chitchatting your fellow survivors.

And that's where it sinks. It's an adventure game that's mostly dialog where the dialog isn't interesting. Every reviewer was going on about how great the writing is but the dialog is so wrote and pedestrian. I guess it serves me right given the source material and its fans.

The other problem is that it's impossible to take slow zombies seriously anymore (even George Romero himself admitted such in the 90s remake of Night of the Living Dead). In order for them to be a threat you have to make the characters clumsy idiots to the point that you stop rooting for them. In the first 5 minutes there's no less than 7 trips and weapon fumbles. Alpha Protocol did all this as a complement to all the action. Walking Dead does a worse job when it's the entire focus.

Supposed to be huge branching depending on what you say and what you do, but it's mostly mild dialog changes. Everything you say will piss one person off but make another happy. Now choose which survivor you'll save. It's only slightly less transparent and forced than Mass Effect's "choose who will go on suicide mission."

I mostly petered out before the end of the first episode, checking out at a scene where slow zombies snuck up on two people in the open during broad daylight. Maybe someone can tell me if it gets better.
NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
The Walking Dead game by fabio 10/31/2012, 6:38pm PDT NEW
    ROTE NT by fabio 10/31/2012, 6:39pm PDT NEW
        Alpha Protocol was supposed to be in reference to the dialog changes by fabio 10/31/2012, 6:41pm PDT NEW
            It's really bad. It only has writing and it got the writing wrong. by Gutsby 11/01/2012, 6:59pm PDT NEW
    Re: The Walking Dead game by Mischief Maker 11/01/2012, 7:29pm PDT NEW
        the scariest zombies are the kind that talk and use tools and weapons by irony 11/03/2012, 1:57am PDT NEW
            What sort of games have zombies like that though? by Pac n' Pal 11/04/2012, 2:32pm PST NEW
                What about Resident Evil 5? NT by Pal 11/04/2012, 2:33pm PST NEW
                    Black zombies are naturally more athletic. NT by Worm 11/04/2012, 3:08pm PST NEW
                Siren and Forbidden Siren! by Gutsby 11/04/2012, 4:57pm PST NEW
                    Siren is the biggest case of interesting story/atmosphere worst game I've seen by fabio 03/02/2013, 2:51pm PST NEW
                I suppose almost all modern zombies NT by welp 04/12/2014, 3:14am PDT NEW
    bleh by fabio 11/04/2012, 1:20am PST NEW
        The 2nd episode in case you were curious by re: 11/09/2012, 11:46pm PST NEW
            fuuuuck (spoilers fuck this story) by fabio 01/15/2013, 5:57pm PST NEW
                This is the perfect game for you to review in its entirety. NT by Gutsby 02/19/2013, 1:33pm PST NEW
                    I agree with this man. NT by Souffle of Pain 02/19/2013, 6:11pm PST NEW
    I'll try to move all the Walking Dead threads here. NT by Ice Cream Jonsey 02/18/2013, 12:50pm PST NEW
    The name of this game should be The Talking Heads. by Jerry Whorebach 03/02/2013, 10:50am PST NEW
        How you holding up, Jerry? NT by Talking Dead protagonist 03/02/2013, 12:04pm PST NEW
    Been playing these recently, I lapped that shit up. Love them NT by Eurotrash 08/10/2014, 2:17am PDT NEW
 
powered by pointy