Forum Overview :: RedLetterMedia
 
I think they should be forced to watch regular movies if they're going to by complain about bad ones. 01/23/2026, 6:03pm PST


Part 2 is out. It's funny and good, but I still got irrationally angry when they didn't recognize the plot of Duet from Arthur Hiller's The Man in the Glass Booth.

Speaking of Arthur Hiller, I meant to bring up The Americanization of Emily in a post about James Garner I wrote a million years ago. It's really good! Not Garner's best role - that was obviously Rockford - but probably the best single piece of work he was ever involved with. It's a World War II movie that's really about Vietnam, so it's like the only anti-war World War II movie not made by a former Axis power. Even The Bridge on the River Kwai ended up flip-flopping by the end. Here is an excerpt from my favourite contemporaneous review of The Bridge on the River Kwai, by The Village Voice's Jerry Tallmer:

Let us return for a moment to the young medic and dwell on him. He is, as I say, that beautiful thing, the perfect neutral. He fights not, neither does he build the bridge. He won’t even participate in ceremonies attending the opening of the bridge. He is above the battle; he has clean hands; he s an Observer. He says so, to Guinness, several times over, to which his poor colonel is only allowed to reply: “You’re a good doctor, Jones” — Smith? Naismith? No-namesmith? the blank is significant — “but you’ve got a lot to learn about the army.” What I shall say now is purely personal, private, and bigoted, indeed absurd, but whenever I heard young Naismith saying “Madness! Madness!” as I stared through that windshield, I kept seeing in his place the scared simian face of young Albie X, whom I once went to camp with and later heard tell me there was nothing ever worth fighting for, he had seen some movies of planes blown clean into dust as soon as a bullet hit them, and later still was encountered for the last time at a cocktail party on 55th Street, now a British ambulance driver back on furlough from Africa, still telling me, with a defeated smirk I cannot communicate on paper, that there was nothing, just nothing, ever worth fighting for. Soon after he became a homosexual. I said that this was going to be bigoted and absurd.


Oh, for the days before M*A*S*H, when New York's most liberal rag could comfortably accuse serving combat medics of cowardice and, indeed, faggotry.
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
RLM beats SF Academy by Mysterio 01/16/2026, 5:51pm PST NEW
    I think they should be forced to watch regular movies if they're going to by complain about bad ones. 01/23/2026, 6:03pm PST NEW
        Re: I think they should be forced to watch regular movies if they're going to by I Hate Epic 01/23/2026, 8:01pm PST NEW
            Rafiki and JW week................ loving it. NT by ya boi malformed penis 01/23/2026, 11:14pm PST NEW
    Stranger Things got so bad, it became their Discovery parody skit by but Ebert kept a stiff upper lip 01/23/2026, 7:06pm PST NEW
 
powered by pointy