Forum Overview :: Peter Molyneux's The Movies
 
Disagree completely by Ice Cream Jonsey 02/06/2019, 10:01am PST
RetroRomper wrote:

Just finished a little over half of episode one of the new season and absolutely nothing happened: the whole episode was full of technobabble, cheap jokes, gags, and set ups for gratuitous action scenes. Almost nothing in the episode made any logical sense and they played up whatever stereotypes the characters fall into. Just a complete waste of time.


This show needed Captain Pike really, really badly. It's a whole new show. Instead of a bunch of weirdos that don't know how to do anything there is actual direction in the episodes.

The "Spock's sister" angle is dumb, but if the show is going to be improved by bringing back a marginal character in Pike and making us care about him then I can forgive the eyeroll nature of Michael being Spock's sister as a retcon. And it is very much improved by linking itself to the Trek that came before.

I was going to post about how fucking stupid it was to give her a male name, but I decided to look it up. It's worse than I thought!

Series creator Bryan Fuller deliberately gave Martin-Green's character a traditionally male name, which he had done with the female leads (George, Jaye and Chuck) in three of his previous series. Martin-Green decided that the character was named after her father.[7] Executive producer Aaron Harberts spoke to TV Guide and explained the reason for calling the character a traditionally male name, explaining, "We've worked on many shows with Bryan and it's a motif. It's his signature move to name his lead women with names that would typically be associated as male."[8] He felt the name was "cool and different"[9] and pitched it himself explaining, "[I was] thinking of female columnist Michael Sneed, who writes for the Chicago Sun-Times, and The Bangles' bassist Michael Steele."


It's important to me that you all recognize that the reason it was done was because it was "cool and different" and literally the sentence before this guy says he does it all the time. WOW. Imagine being that awful in your thinking and failing upwards to where you get to create a Star Trek show. Holy shit.

Anyway, it doesn't matter that much because the show is good. I didn't bother finishing the first season. Season 2 episode 2 was really great. Some may say it was even touching! Oh, the other dumb thing was that they got rid of the yellow uniforms. I feel that acknowledging the source material in anyway is a mortal crime to a lot of people that work in the playgrounds of others. (Daredevil being in a dumb looking black set of pajamas in season 3 is another example.)
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
Star Trek: Discovery Season 2 by RetroRomper 01/18/2019, 4:45am PST NEW
    Disagree completely by Ice Cream Jonsey 02/06/2019, 10:01am PST NEW
        Oh, I thought it was a "Mister Saavik" sort of thing. NT by Not woke, just pretentious. 02/06/2019, 11:26am PST NEW
            It's a woke pretention NT by Vested Id 02/06/2019, 1:03pm PST NEW
        Would you mind actually replying to my points? NT by RetroRomper 02/07/2019, 12:21am PST NEW
            Yes. But first - what was illogical about the first episode? by Ice Cream Jonsey 02/07/2019, 10:35am PST NEW
                =( NT by Ice Cream Jonsey 02/10/2019, 12:05pm PST NEW
    maybe you should watch Star Wars instead by Dr. No 02/07/2019, 10:03pm PST NEW
 
powered by pointy