Forum Overview :: Reviews
 
Okay, I've got a legit complaint. by Mischief Maker 07/08/2018, 6:44am PDT
No not the gender pronouns (boo-hoo), no, not the Unity engine choking on large overhead maps (Satellite Reign had insane load times, too). It's the fact that you're limited to four mechs.

Why this is a problem is ironically because of the game's greatest strength: its excellent streamlined interface. Playing the Battletech boardgame was a very involved process with complicated character sheets simulating these complex sci fi vehicles, representing armor as individual circles to be blacked out as they take damage, heat levels constantly filled in and erased, and so on. This was fun work for an imaginative middle-schooler, but it was still work nevertheless and so the limit of 4 on 4 made it actually possible to finish a game in a day.

But in Battletech the videogame that's all handled by the computer in the background and the end result is... kinda dull. Don't get me wrong, a complex story map can still be a blast to navigate, but in general mech-on-mech random missions it feels like a heavily stripped down SRPG. You just move and shoot. The only real dilemma is choosing between moving to a hex with the highest amount of evasion and cover verses a hex with optimal firing position. There's no overwatch, no area-denial artillery, and with jump jets not even any choke points. The battletech board game rules were very simple in many aspects to make up for all the busywork but now that the computer's taking care of the busywork the only gameplay left for the player is too damn simple.

It's kinda like how in the Etrian Odyssey games if they took out the manual map-drawing mechanics you'd realize their dungeon layouts are incredibly simple and boring compared to other games in the genre like The Dark Spire.

Now this could still work if they massively increased the numbers of mechs on a map and included vehicle artillery backup or city maps, but I don't know if their engine can handle it.

As much as that game does everything in its power to try to make me hate it based on terrible aesthetic choices, Sanctus Reach in its current patched state is way more fun than Battletech.
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
Battletech first impressions by Mischief Maker 04/24/2018, 4:35pm PDT NEW
    Did you even play XCOM? NT by A bloo bloo lost a soldier to RNG 04/24/2018, 7:24pm PDT NEW
    Metacritic is a bunch of crybabies complaining this thing doesn't run on their by potato tablets. 04/24/2018, 8:10pm PDT NEW
        I also think the nonbinary gender pronoun OPTION triggerd the hysterical right. by Mischief Maker 04/26/2018, 2:50pm PDT NEW
            Please tell me this game includes the Warrior H-7 Attack Helicopter NT by Roop 04/26/2018, 6:00pm PDT NEW
                No choppers, just turrets & armored vehicles NT by Rey Mysterio Jr. 04/26/2018, 10:30pm PDT NEW
                    Egregious! NT by Roop 04/27/2018, 10:46am PDT NEW
            Not that I'm paying attention but I don't think the game has called me they once NT by Worm 04/28/2018, 6:57pm PDT NEW
    More thoughts. by Mischief Maker 04/25/2018, 7:42pm PDT NEW
        Options -> Disable Dynamic Attack Camera NT by Problem solved 04/25/2018, 9:07pm PDT NEW
        I think I'm shelving it for now, waiting for a balance pass by Rey Mysterio Jr. 04/26/2018, 9:16am PDT NEW
            Reloaded the game, changed my mind maybe by Rey Mysterio Jr. 04/26/2018, 10:36pm PDT NEW
        Chevrons! by Mischief Maker 04/29/2018, 2:58pm PDT NEW
            The LOS cone also shows optimal and minimum ranges NT by Rey Mysterio Jr. 04/29/2018, 4:17pm PDT NEW
    Okay, I've got a legit complaint. by Mischief Maker 07/08/2018, 6:44am PDT NEW
    I think I figured out what's behind the whole nonbinary gender option. by Mischief Maker 08/18/2018, 4:14pm PDT NEW
 
powered by pointy