Forum Overview :: Super Mario Odyssey
 
I'm still liking it a lot, but I did get a bit exhausted mid-late game by mark 05/22/2018, 8:06pm PDT
Oh cool, another kingdom with 80 Power Moons???

I'm only at ~300 Power Moons and got about 220 of those through the core plot line, so I undoubtably haven't even started with the really lame challenges.

Pros:
Cappy is fun and the enemy-possessing puzzles are enjoyable (although probably not great game design).
The challenges zones are really good.
The general reward structure of "if you can get there (you can), there is a Power Moon or a pile of coins" is still good.
I liked running around as Mario 64's Mario.

This points to the fact that the right way to do the collectables is to do what the best parts of Mario 64 did, which was to present a giant jungle gym with rewards for doing stuff the designers thought was cool, however you wanted to do it.

Cons:
The game is probably too big.
Mario's move set is too huge
No one has 1000 good ideas.
They have somehow added GRINDING to a Mario game. This element feels more like a freemium game.

Rafiki's rating makes complete sense, but I haven't played a Mario in a while and they are just so polished. I'll go 9/10 with the caveat I need to find a Wii U so I can try Super Mario 3D World.
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
IMPRESSIONS by Rafiki 10/30/2017, 4:48pm PDT NEW
    It's fine, but massively overrated. 8 is about right, I'd even go as low as 7. by Rafiki 11/25/2017, 8:33pm PST NEW
    I'm still liking it a lot, but I did get a bit exhausted mid-late game by mark 05/22/2018, 8:06pm PDT NEW
        Running out of steam on these moons by mark 05/29/2018, 8:19am PDT NEW
 
powered by pointy