Forum Overview :: Mac Hall Complaints Department
 
Strawmaning by the world's greatest socially aware Transformers fan by a bit late to the party on this one 03/20/2014, 7:55am PDT
A few weeks ago, Image Comics publisher Eric Stephenson gave an interview at the Comic Book Resources site and had a few things to say about the industry and growth and reaching readers

http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=article&id=51172

relevant parts to this post:

We talk about being obsessed with expanding our audience, but if publishing lesser versions of people’s favorite cartoons, toys, and TV shows is the best we can do, then we are doomed to failure.

Simply reframing work from other media as comic books is the absolute worst representation of comics.

We can invite readers to innovate with us, but repurposing someone else’s ideas as comic books isn’t innovation – at best, it’s imitation, and we are all so much better than that.

New creativity that is native to comics is what makes this industry stronger. It shows what comics do, what comics can BE.

[snip]

TRANSFORMERS comics will never be the real thing. GI JOE comics will never be the real thing. STAR WARS comics will never be the real thing. Those comics are for fans that love the real thing so much, they want more – but there’s the important thing to understand: They don’t want more comics – they just want more of the thing they love. Those comics are accessories to an existing interest, an add-on, an upsell, easy surplus for the parent products – icing on the cake.

Comics are so much more than that, and this industry has existed as long as it has because of the ingenuity of men and women all over the world who yearn to share the fruits of their imaginations, not simply find new ways to prolong the life of existing IPs.


Dave Willis, creator of Shortpacked!, apparently 1) Read this part 2) Shat his pants and 3) Started drawing this comic

http://www.shortpacked.com/index.php?id=2026

What Mr. Stephenson said was that Transformers comics weren't the real thing because the real thing as far as Transformers go are the toys. The Transformers comics are a derivative tie-in product to a non-comic franchise. Mr. Dave Willis read that and, as his doughy manchild face contorted in nerd-rage, understood it as Stephenson claiming they weren't real comics; which is a very different point and one that Stephenson wasn't making. And then he decided to make a comic where he strawmans Stephenson by presenting him as an egotistical boob trying to promote Image Comics as the only comics that matter

Also, possibly, Dave Willis was mad because he thought his comics, what with their repeated use of the same characters in different settings and leaning heavily on pop-culture nostalgia (when he isn't busy trying to milk the SJW/tumblr crowd for approval) were being called part of the problem. That and he saw Stephenson taking a shot at Transformers and oh God forbid somebody say something negative about anything related to Transformers; because only Willis is allowed to say negative things about Transformers...as, like, literally half of his comics.
NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
Strawmaning by the world's greatest socially aware Transformers fan by a bit late to the party on this one 03/20/2014, 7:55am PDT NEW
    Spawn publisher pshes Carl Barks' Donald Duck comics as "not the real shit" NT by Jerry Whorebach 03/20/2014, 9:57am PDT NEW
    Jesus and watching all his stupid commentors fall in line! by Worm 03/20/2014, 10:51am PDT NEW
        My grammatical error rate is at an all time high, lately. I have no excuse. NT by Worm 03/20/2014, 10:52am PDT NEW
    IDW's 'GI Joe: Cobra' comic is a billion trillion times superior than any other NT by GI Joe thing ever. -Last 03/20/2014, 1:20pm PDT NEW
        But he's right that licensed comics are fake and suck shit. NT by Last 03/20/2014, 1:22pm PDT NEW
    We did indeed cover this on swc a while back. by kate leth 03/20/2014, 7:27pm PDT NEW
        You missed the tumblr post about his childhood and drawing sex by HEIDEGGER 03/20/2014, 7:41pm PDT NEW
 
powered by pointy