Forum Overview :: XIII
 
Re: How I feel about the inclusion of proper nouns by Ray of Light 04/04/2013, 3:48am PDT
Gentleman Jim Browser wrote:

How do you feel about the inclusion of proper nouns?
I am all for it!

See, the problem behind the word list problem is, competitive Scrabble is run by old people and old people cannot learn new things. They know the word list is bad but it's all they've got. And the owners of Scrabble will not hire a bunch of lexicographers to fix it, they don't give a fuck, they make money licensing the logo on the word list no matter what it contains.

So I would go further, and make Google the arbiter of word choice. Pick a hundred obscure-but-legit words to form the Dow Jones Scrabble Acceptability Index, and require that every play has 50% as many hits as the index (with language filter, of course, and maybe "-twl -scrabble" to cleanse legacy wordlists from the results). PSY, PUTIN, LOLOL, and IDGAF are now good, while brazen bullshit like CWM, CHLORIN, POILU, VROW are gone. JAPAN and EMAIL remain good but for the right reasons.

An exciting and useful wrinkle is that words would emerge and disappear over time, counteracting the natural advantage given to ancient Scrabble players. People who are legitimately well-read or good at crosswords (not me) would finally receive the edge this game promises (but denies) them.
PREVIOUS NEXT REPLY QUOTE
 
Analysis of a Scrabble Game. by Ray of Light 07/24/2007, 4:00am PDT NEW
    You could have been somebody, Ray. NT by Quentin Beck 07/24/2007, 5:59pm PDT NEW
        We're all very impressed, Ray. We just wish you'd set your mind to more accessab NT by le things. 07/26/2007, 5:18pm PDT NEW
    30 months later by Ray of Light 03/17/2010, 8:33pm PDT NEW
        Re: 30 months later by Gentleman Jim Browser 04/07/2010, 12:17am PDT NEW
            I want an answer you jerk! NT by Gentleman Jim Browser 01/17/2011, 7:48pm PST NEW
                Re: I want an answer you jerk! by John McEnroe 01/18/2011, 12:07am PST NEW
            Re: How I feel about the inclusion of proper nouns by Ray of Light 04/04/2013, 3:48am PDT NEW
    I've always considered competitive Scrabble a horror show by BUT....!!!! 06/12/2023, 12:26am PDT NEW
 
powered by pointy